Why Auto ApproveResourcesFAQ
Log In(844) 336-3365
Why Auto ApproveResourcesFAQAuto RefinanceAuto Lease PurchaseMotorcycle RefinanceLog In
(844) 336-3365
A dealer presenting a car to a customer

Should I Buy a Car From a Dealership?

Education | 10/23/2026 04:00

Here’s what you need to know.


  • There are a few common ways today to buy a car. You can buy from a dealership in person or from a reputable online seller, or if you’re interested in a used vehicle, you can also purchase a used car directly from the owner.

  • There are pros and cons to each option. Which you choose will depend on your budget, vehicle needs, and personal preferences and comfort level.

  • If you choose to buy from a dealership, you should go in prepared. Make sure you know the current market and what you’re looking for; get pre-approved ahead; and don’t be afraid to shop around, walk away, or negotiate on rate as well as terms.


Read on to take a closer look at whether you should buy your next vehicle from a dealership and why.

How to Decide If You Should Buy A Car From A Dealership: Your Guide

Car dealerships used to be the only name in the game if you wanted a new car, but nowadays you have another option: buying a car online. So how can you decide whether or not buying a car from a dealership is the right move for you?

What Are The Advantages Of Buying A Car At A Dealership?

Buying a car from a dealership has some significant advantages over buying online. The human element is one of the top advantages, as you can actually talk to a salesperson and let them guide you through your options. 


In short:


  • You can get advice

  • You can negotiate

  • You may be able to get a manufacturer incentive

You Can Get Advice

Car dealerships have salespeople who can help you immensely if you are unsure on the exact vehicle you want. Even if you know the make and model you want, there are endless options when it comes to upgrades and trim levels. Salespeople can help explain your options and pick out the exact car that will work for you.

You Can Negotiate

Dealerships also provide a way for you to negotiate. When you buy a car online, you are unable to negotiate the price. Everything is cut and dry online, whereas shopping at a dealership will allow you to cut down the sticker price or possibly have some fees waived. 

You May Get A Manufacturer Incentive

Buying at a dealership means that you may be eligible for manufacturer incentives. These incentives can vary greatly and may include 0% financing, a cash rebate, or equipment upgrade. 

What Are The Disadvantages Of Buying A Car At A Dealership?

There are some disadvantages to buying a car at a dealership as well. Your options may be more limited and you may get swayed into options that you do not want or need. So for some people, buying online may be a more comfortable option.


In short:


  • It takes more time

  • You get fewer options

  • Dealerships can involve sales pressure and upselling

It Takes More Time

It’s hard to beat the convenience of shopping for a new car from the comfort of your home. Buying a car at a dealership will take much more time and may require multiple trips to multiple dealerships to get the car that you truly want. The negotiation process will take more time as well, as you cannot simply click a button and wait for your car to arrive.

You May Have Fewer Options

When you buy online, everything is at your fingertips. Whatever make, model, color, and options that you want are available to you. This may not be true for your local dealership, which may not even carry the make and model car that you are interested in. 

You May Get Persuaded Into Something You Don’t Need

Salespeople earn commissions, so it’s in their best interest to increase the amount you are paying as much as possible. And this may mean that you will get talked into something that you don’t really want or need. It’s much easier to simply go online and select exactly what you want. You may also find that it is more difficult to walk away, even if you know that the car is not right for you.

What Are The Other Options for Buying a Car?

You can also purchase a vehicle:


  • Online

  • Pre-owned from the previous owner


Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of these options.

Online

Purchasing a vehicle online from a trusted vendor like Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds, or Carvana is an increasingly popular way to shop for cars. If you know the model of car you want and your budget, these sites can offer you selection and convenience a dealership often can’t, and shopping around online can help you find a better deal on a vehicle than you might get at a local dealership, depending on a variety of factors. You also avoid the pressure and upselling that can come with dealership sales, which many online car buyers found to be a plus.


One of the downsides of purchasing online is that, of course, you can’t test drive the vehicle in the traditional way, though most reputable online car sales will include an at home test drive period or money back guarantee. However, in a PC Magazine survey, the top complaints among those who purchased cars online were about the return period or process.


It may also be harder to negotiate a good rate when purchasing online, since you’re not negotiating directly with anyone. Comparing prices and rates before making a decision is always a good idea, and if you feel you didn’t get the rate deserved, you can always refinance your vehicle to a lower rate.

From a previous owner

Buying a used car directly from its current owner is another option for buying a car. This can be a great option for saving money, but does require more legwork than the other options. You’ll need to get the vehicle inspected, check its market value, run a VIN report, and so on to make sure it’s safe to drive and being offered for a decent price. There’s also some paperwork you’ll need to do that a dealership or online seller would likely handle, like filing a bill of sale and getting the title certificate signed over to you.


One of the other limitations of this option is that it can be hard to find direct sellers and the selection will typically be quite limited. However, with this option, you may be able to avoid financing altogether or find a good price on a solid older vehicle if your budget is tight.

How Can I Prepare For Buying A Car At A Dealership?

If you decide that a dealership is your best option for purchasing a car, there are a number of steps you can take to make sure that you get the best deal (and best vehicle) possible for you:


  1. Do your research

  2. Get pre-approved

  3. Shop around

  4. Take time to understand your financing options

  5. Be prepared to walk away

Do Your Research

Do not make the mistake of going into a dealership unprepared. You should have a loose idea of what you are looking for (at the very least, you should have a list of what you are looking for in a new car) and you should have a loose idea of the price. The more you know about what you want ahead of time, the more you can focus on the specifics of what’s available to you. This will help you spot if you are being taken advantage of or if a dealer price is fair. 

 

You should also know how much you can afford to pay every month in car payments. Your total cost for transportation (car payments, insurance, maintenance, gas, parking, etc.) should never be more than 20% of your total monthly income. 

Get Pre-Approved

Getting pre-approved before you set foot in a dealership will help you in a few different ways. First off, it will show the salesperson that you are serious about buying a car and are prepared to do so. It will also mean that if the dealership wants you to finance with them they will need to negotiate against your pre-approved financing offer.

Shop Around

Do not go to just one car dealership when you are looking to buy a new car. Going to a few different dealerships will give you some more negotiating power and let you compare offers. 

Break Down Your Financing Into Components

When dealerships sell you a car, they tend to focus on your monthly financing payments. They want you to focus on your monthly payments rather than showing you the overall picture. But this can get confusing. Monthly payments are largely determined by your repayment period. Any car is affordable if you are given a long enough time to pay it off. The longer that you are repaying your loan however, the more money you will pay over the life of it. 

 

Instead, focus on the out the door price first—the total cost of the car. Try to negotiate your sticker price down in a separate transaction before moving on to how exactly you will pay for the car. You should also ask about the rate you’re being offered and compare it to what you were pre-approved for. You can negotiate on your rate just as you can the car price. This can help you dodge some dealership markups.


Putting a solid down payment down will help keep your payments affordable and help ensure your loan won’t become underwater. 

Be Prepared To Walk Away

Dealerships can be intimidating and there may be a lot of pressure to sign on the dotted line, but you should only sign when you are 100% happy with all of the terms. 


Make sure that you have the exact car that you want and that the financing terms are fair. Dealers want to pressure you into making a sale because they know that once you leave the dealership, their odds of making the sale have decreased significantly. But do not let their pressure sway you into a car and a deal that doesn’t fit with what you want.

Now You Can Decide If You Should Buy From A Car Dealership Or Not 

There are pros and cons to buying a vehicle at a dealership, but if you decide to purchase a car that way, be sure to do your research and stand your ground.

 

And if you got a bad deal on your dealership financing, refinancing is the best way to secure the lower rate and lower monthly payment you deserve. Get started with Auto Approve today to see how much you could be saving!


GET A QUOTE IN 60 SECONDS

More Resources